A car dealer can mark up your loan rate. One extra percentage point can cost $843.
What the Reel says
A car dealer can mark up your loan rate. One extra percentage point can cost $843.
The dealer sends your application to about five lenders, then shows you only one loan.
The lender tells the dealer the rate you're approved for. The dealer can offer you a higher one.
That's how the dealer gets paid: the lender shares part of the extra interest.
For example, say a $30,000, five-year loan is approved at 6%. The dealer offers 7%.
$14 more a month
$843 more in all
Like the car's price, the rate is negotiable.
A bank or credit union quote gives you a number to compare.
Your credit helps set the starting number. What the dealer adds is a price you can question.
Sources and assumptions
- CFPB: What is a buy rate for an auto loan? (last reviewed Jan. 30, 2024): A buy rate is the interest rate a financial institution quotes to the dealer; the rate offered to you may be higher to compensate the dealer and is called the contract rate; dealers and lenders are not required to offer the best rates available; auto loan terms are negotiable. (checked 2026-11-10)
- CFPB: What is dealer-arranged financing? (updated Apr. 28, 2023): Dealer rates are generally higher because they are the buy rate plus additional interest; most dealers reach out to roughly five lenders and present one loan; buyers can ask whether other offers had lower rates; a bank or credit union quote lets you compare offers. (checked 2026-11-10)
- CFPB: CFPB to hold auto lenders accountable for illegal discriminatory markup (March 2013): Indirect auto lenders often let dealers charge a rate higher than the lender's buy rate ('dealer markup') and share part of the revenue from that higher rate with the dealer. (checked 2026-11-10)
- CFPB and DOJ: Resolution with Toyota Motor Credit (Feb. 2, 2016): Toyota Motor Credit permitted dealers to mark up interest rates as much as 2.5 percent; the new policy capped markups at 1.25 percentage points for loans of 5 years or less and 1 point for longer loans. (checked 2026-11-10)
Assumptions:
- Fictional loan: $30,000 borrowed, 60 monthly payments (5 years), fixed rate, no fees, no down payment or trade-in counted, and every payment made on time.
- Fictional buy rate of 6% a year and contract rate of 7% a year: a 1-percentage-point markup. Real buy rates depend on credit, the lender, the car and the term.
- Standard amortizing-loan payment formula with monthly compounding (rate ÷ 12). Real contracts may differ slightly in day counting and rounding.
- Not every dealer marks up every loan, and markup caps vary by lender. Some lenders pay dealers a flat fee instead, and manufacturer promotional rates (like 0%) work differently.
- The 2.5-point figure is Toyota Motor Credit's allowance before its 2016 settlement, given as history and not as today's market norm.


