Money Facts To Know
← All posts

Fictional $300,000 of shares, sold: inherited, $0 gain. Gifted, $250,000 gain

· View on Instagram · View on Facebook

Fictional $300,000 of shares, sold: inherited, $0 gain. Gifted, $250,000 gain
It feels like the same shares. Whether shares are given now or left in a will, it seems like the tax when they're sold should be the same. The rules treat the two differently.

It feels like the same shares

Whether shares are given now or left in a will, it seems like the tax when they're sold should be the same. The rules treat the two differently.

Your gain starts with your basis. A taxable gain is the sale price minus your basis. Basis is generally what was paid for the asset, and how you receive it can change it.

Your gain starts with your basis

A taxable gain is the sale price minus your basis. Basis is generally what was paid for the asset, and how you receive it can change it.

Source: IRS Topic No. 703

Inherited shares get a new basis. Inherited in a regular (taxable) brokerage account: your basis is generally the value on the date of death. On these fictional shares, the basis steps up from the $50,000 the original owner paid to $300,000.

Inherited shares get a new basis

Inherited in a regular (taxable) brokerage account: your basis is generally the value on the date of death. On these fictional shares, the basis steps up from the $50,000 the original owner paid to $300,000.

Source: IRS Publication 551; 26 U.S.C. §1014(c)

Gifted shares keep the old basis. Gifted: when the gift is worth at least the giver's basis, your basis is generally the giver's adjusted basis, usually what they paid. Here the $50,000 carries over.

Gifted shares keep the old basis

Gifted: when the gift is worth at least the giver's basis, your basis is generally the giver's adjusted basis, usually what they paid. Here the $50,000 carries over.

Source: IRS Publication 551

Same sale, two different gains. Fictional shares in a taxable brokerage account cost $50,000 and were worth $300,000 at death or the gift. Sold right away for $300,000 (federal, no selling costs), only the basis differs.

Same sale, two different gains

Fictional shares in a taxable brokerage account cost $50,000 and were worth $300,000 at death or the gift. Sold right away for $300,000 (federal, no selling costs), only the basis differs.

The math: $300,000 − $300,000 = $0 vs $300,000 − $50,000 = $250,000

Source: IRS Publication 551, federal rules as of Oct 2026

When the example stops applying. Inherited shares inside a traditional IRA or 401(k) get no step-up; withdrawals are generally taxed as income. Gift tax actually paid can raise a gift's basis. Other cases: alternate valuation date, community property, Form 8971.

When the example stops applying

Inherited shares inside a traditional IRA or 401(k) get no step-up; withdrawals are generally taxed as income. Gift tax actually paid can raise a gift's basis. Other cases: alternate valuation date, community property, Form 8971.

Source: IRS Publication 551; 26 U.S.C. §1014(c); IRS Publication 559

What to check before shares move. Before shares change hands, look up the giver's adjusted cost basis and the value on the transfer date, and keep records of both. This post shows the gain, not the tax owed.

What to check before shares move

Before shares change hands, look up the giver's adjusted cost basis and the value on the transfer date, and keep records of both. This post shows the gain, not the tax owed.

Sources and assumptions

Assumptions:

The short version

Follow @moneyfactstoknowSave this post on Instagram

More posts