Money Facts To Know
← All posts

Roth IRA isn't locked: contributions come out first, federal tax-free

· View on Instagram · View on Facebook

Roth IRA isn't locked: contributions come out first, federal tax-free
Not every early withdrawal is penalized. Many people assume every dollar taken from a Roth IRA before 59½ (the usual retirement-account age) gets taxed and hit with a 10% penalty. For direct contributions, the federal rules don't work that way.

Not every early withdrawal is penalized

Many people assume every dollar taken from a Roth IRA before 59½ (the usual retirement-account age) gets taxed and hit with a 10% penalty. For direct contributions, the federal rules don't work that way.

Source: IRS Pub 590-B (2025); IRS Topic 557

Withdrawals come out in a fixed order. Direct contributions come out first, then converted money (including pre-tax money rolled in), oldest first, then earnings. All your Roth IRAs count as one. Roth 401(k) rollovers split: contributions with tier 1, earnings with tier 3.

Withdrawals come out in a fixed order

Direct contributions come out first, then converted money (including pre-tax money rolled in), oldest first, then earnings. All your Roth IRAs count as one. Roth 401(k) rollovers split: contributions with tier 1, earnings with tier 3.

Source: IRS Pub 590-B (2025); 26 USC 408A(d)(4); 26 CFR 1.408A-10; IRS Instructions for Form 8606 (2025)

Meet the fictional $22,000 Roth IRA. A fictional 40-year-old's Roth IRA holds $22,000: $18,000 of direct contributions plus $4,000 of earnings. No conversions, rollovers or earlier withdrawals.

Meet the fictional $22,000 Roth IRA

A fictional 40-year-old's Roth IRA holds $22,000: $18,000 of direct contributions plus $4,000 of earnings. No conversions, rollovers or earlier withdrawals.

Source: Fictional example; arithmetic checked

Taking out $10,000 costs $0 in federal tax. In the fictional account, a $10,000 withdrawal comes entirely from contributions. That means $0 federal income tax and no 10% additional tax, and even $18,000 would cost $0.

Taking out $10,000 costs $0 in federal tax

In the fictional account, a $10,000 withdrawal comes entirely from contributions. That means $0 federal income tax and no 10% additional tax, and even $18,000 would cost $0.

The math: $10,000 ≤ $18,000 contributed → $0 taxable

Source: IRS Pub 590-B (2025)

Where the free ride stops. Take out all $22,000 and the last $4,000 is earnings. Before 59½, with no exception, that part is taxable income plus the 10% additional tax. Assumed 22% federal bracket, tax year 2026.

Where the free ride stops

Take out all $22,000 and the last $4,000 is earnings. Before 59½, with no exception, that part is taxable income plus the 10% additional tax. Assumed 22% federal bracket, tax year 2026.

The math: $4,000 × 22% + $4,000 × 10% = $1,280

Source: IRS Pub 590-B (2025); IRS Topic 557

When this example stops applying. Converted money has its own 5-year clock for the 10% tax. Earnings are tax-free only after 5 tax years from your first Roth contribution or conversion, plus age 59½, disability, death or a first home ($10,000 lifetime).

When this example stops applying

Converted money has its own 5-year clock for the 10% tax. Earnings are tax-free only after 5 tax years from your first Roth contribution or conversion, plus age 59½, disability, death or a first home ($10,000 lifetime).

The math: State tax rules can differ from the federal rules here.

Source: IRS Pub 590-B (2025); 26 USC 408A(d)(2); IRS Topic 557

Three things to check first. Add up your direct contributions (Form 5498 shows each year's; Form 8606, line 22 takes the total in a year you withdraw), check for conversions or rollovers, and note your first Roth contribution year.

Three things to check first

Add up your direct contributions (Form 5498 shows each year's; Form 8606, line 22 takes the total in a year you withdraw), check for conversions or rollovers, and note your first Roth contribution year.

The math: Putting money back is a new deposit: 2026 limit $7,500 under 50; income limits apply.

Source: IRS Instructions for Form 8606 (2025); IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498; IRS IR-2025-111

Sources and assumptions

Assumptions:

The short version

Follow @moneyfactstoknowSave this post on Instagram

More posts