Money Facts To Know
← All posts

Free 1.5% card or $95 fee at 3%? The break-even spend

· View on Instagram · View on Facebook

Free 1.5% card or $95 fee at 3%? The break-even spend
Neither shortcut settles it. Two shortcuts are common: the higher percentage wins, or an annual fee is a waste. Neither works until you know your spend in the bonus category, where a card pays its higher rate.

Neither shortcut settles it

Two shortcuts are common: the higher percentage wins, or an annual fee is a waste. Neither works until you know your spend in the bonus category, where a card pays its higher rate.

The fee is repaid by the rate gap. Fictional card A charges $95 and pays 3% in one category. Card B is free and pays 1.5% on everything. Both pay 1.5% elsewhere.

The fee is repaid by the rate gap

Fictional card A charges $95 and pays 3% in one category. Card B is free and pays 1.5% on everything. Both pay 1.5% elsewhere.

The math: $95 ÷ (3% − 1.5%) = $6,333 a year, about $528 a month

Source: Own math on fictional cards

Same cards, different spend, different winner. At $4,000 a year in the category, B is ahead by $35. At $10,000, A is ahead by $55. Both figures are net of the fee, for one year.

Same cards, different spend, different winner

At $4,000 a year in the category, B is ahead by $35. At $10,000, A is ahead by $55. Both figures are net of the fee, for one year.

The math: $4,000 × 3% − $95 = $25 vs $60; $10,000 × 3% − $95 = $205 vs $150

Source: Own math on fictional cards

A balance can outweigh the rewards. A fictional $2,000 balance carried all year at an assumed 22% APR (annual interest rate) costs about $440 on either card. CFPB: people who carry balances often pay far more in interest and fees than rewards return.

A balance can outweigh the rewards

A fictional $2,000 balance carried all year at an assumed 22% APR (annual interest rate) costs about $440 on either card. CFPB: people who carry balances often pay far more in interest and fees than rewards return.

The math: $2,000 × 22% = $440 a year, more than the $205 or $150 earned at $10,000 of spend.

Source: CFPB, May 2024; own math

Other terms move the break-even. A cap on the 3% category, a first-year fee waiver, a sign-up bonus, points worth under one cent, or a lower rate outside the category move the break-even. The fee recurs, so spending must clear it yearly.

Other terms move the break-even

A cap on the 3% category, a first-year fee waiver, a sign-up bonus, points worth under one cent, or a lower rate outside the category move the break-even. The fee recurs, so spending must clear it yearly.

Source: CFPB, May 2024; own math

One division to redo before applying. If both cards pay the same outside the category, break-even is the annual fee ÷ the rate gap. Find the fee and purchase APR in the rates and fees table. Check the rewards terms for any cap.

One division to redo before applying

If both cards pay the same outside the category, break-even is the annual fee ÷ the rate gap. Find the fee and purchase APR in the rates and fees table. Check the rewards terms for any cap.

Source: CFPB Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.60; formula is own math

Sources and assumptions

Assumptions:

The short version

Follow @moneyfactstoknowSave this post on Instagram

More posts