Money Facts To Know
← All posts

On $9,400 in hand, a fictional 10% loan costs more than 13%

· View on Instagram · View on Facebook

On $9,400 in hand, a fictional 10% loan costs more than 13%
Two offers, one obvious pick?. Offer A: $10,000 at 10% with a 6% origination fee (a one-time charge taken out of the loan). Offer B: $9,400 at 13%, no fee. Either way, you get $9,400. Both are fictional 3-year loans, paid monthly.

Two offers, one obvious pick?

Offer A: $10,000 at 10% with a 6% origination fee (a one-time charge taken out of the loan). Offer B: $9,400 at 13%, no fee. Either way, you get $9,400. Both are fictional 3-year loans, paid monthly.

Source: Fictional offers; assumptions in caption

The fee comes out of your cash. Offer A's $600 fee comes out of the loan, so you get $9,400 but repay $10,000 plus interest. Truth in Lending rules count loan fees as a cost of credit.

The fee comes out of your cash

Offer A's $600 fee comes out of the loan, so you get $9,400 but repay $10,000 plus interest. Truth in Lending rules count loan fees as a cost of credit.

Source: 12 CFR §1026.2(a)(23) and §1026.18(b); CFPB, Reg Z §1026.4

Compare APR, not the rate. The APR counts the fee by relating cash received to payments made. Offer A: 10% rate, 14.31% APR. Offer B: 13% rate, 13.00% APR. It assumes the full term and works best for offers with the same term.

Compare APR, not the rate

The APR counts the fee by relating cash received to payments made. Offer A: 10% rate, 14.31% APR. Offer B: 13% rate, 13.00% APR. It assumes the full term and works best for offers with the same term.

Source: CFPB, Reg Z §1026.22; Ask CFPB (rate vs APR)

Same cash, different total. For the same $9,400 in hand and 36 monthly payments: Offer A is $322.67 a month, $11,616.12 total. Offer B is $316.72 a month, $11,401.92 total.

Same cash, different total

For the same $9,400 in hand and 36 monthly payments: Offer A is $322.67 a month, $11,616.12 total. Offer B is $316.72 a month, $11,401.92 total.

The math: $11,616.12 − $11,401.92 = $214.20 more for the lower rate

Source: CFPB, Reg Z §1026.18 terms; worked calculation, fictional offers

Paying early makes it worse. Make 12 payments, then pay off the balance. Cost is everything paid minus the $9,400 received: Offer A $1,464.64, Offer B $1,062.67. The $600 fee is spread over fewer payments, so it weighs more.

Paying early makes it worse

Make 12 payments, then pay off the balance. Cost is everything paid minus the $9,400 received: Offer A $1,464.64, Offer B $1,062.67. The $600 fee is spread over fewer payments, so it weighs more.

The math: $1,464.64 − $1,062.67 = $401.97 more

Source: Worked calculation, fictional offers; assumes no prepayment penalty (extra fee for early payoff) or fee refund

Three lines to check. Check these lines on each disclosure and compare APR to APR, not to a rate. If a lender adds the fee to the balance, you get the full amount but owe more; APR still counts the fee.

Three lines to check

Check these lines on each disclosure and compare APR to APR, not to a rate. If a lender adds the fee to the balance, you get the full amount but owe more; APR still counts the fee.

Source: CFPB, Reg Z §1026.18

Sources and assumptions

Assumptions:

The short version

Follow @moneyfactstoknowSave this post on Instagram

More posts